APS News | Opinion

You—yes, you—are an advocate, too

Students are frequently missing from science policy discussions. They shouldn't be.

By
Nov. 18, 2026
Three people talk on a marble staircase in an ornate hall.
Attendees at APS’ Congressional Visits Day in Washington, D.C. Students don’t need policy expertise to become advocates — their own stories are enough.
APS

A few months ago, I was invited to be a panelist at the AIP Annual Forum, where I’d have the chance to talk about contributing to science policy advocacy as an early-career scientist.

Perhaps I should have been flattered, but I felt intimidated. Why was I, of all people, being asked to participate? Didn’t they know I was inexperienced? Shouldn’t they have invited someone who knew all about science policy?

Despite my reservations, I decided to attend. In a room full of professional society presidents and executives, I shared my perspectives on why it was so important that students participate as advocates in scientific societies, and how my own involvement had helped me communicate my research more effectively. Many audience members took notes and asked questions, and I had thoughtful conversations with a few attendees afterward. Today, it still feels surreal that I was able to contribute ideas that seasoned veterans in the field valued.

Unfortunately, when it comes to policy advocacy, many students feel out of place or unqualified, as I felt — and many more don’t know how to participate.

This is a problem because students live with the downstream consequences of science policy every day. By science policy, I mean the decisions — made by Congress, federal agencies, states, and even universities — that shape how science and research are paid for, regulated, staffed, and run. For example, immigration policies impact the ability of international students to study in and work in the U.S. From 2024 to 2025, the proportion of non-U.S. citizens who left the U.S. after earning their Ph.D.s nearly doubled, from 16% to 29%. And federal science funding, which has faced the threat of severe cuts, affects how many Ph.D. slots departments can offer, how much funding students receive, and whether multi-year projects can continue. Funding for many undergraduate research experiences, like those that I benefited from in college, has also been cut.

And policy is not only national. For example, there are no standards for graduate student compensation, so funding can vary from school to school or even department to department — an example of an important campus-level policy issue.

So, what role can students play in shaping the science policy that shapes them? Many forums already exist. On campus, students can serve in student government and on faculty committees, which often have regular discussions with university administration. The aerospace engineering program at Georgia Tech, where I’m a graduate student, has both a Student Advisory Council, which primarily serves undergraduates, and a Graduate Student Association.

Professional societies, like the American Physical Society and Society of Physics Students, also offer avenues for policy engagement for students. For example, students can join dedicated APS communities, like the APS Forum on Graduate Student Affairs (FGSA). When I served as chairman of the forum, I led a grassroots advocacy campaign with APS Government Affairs in support of the RESEARCHER Act, which led to more than 1,000 letters sent to congressional representatives and six in-person meetings with their offices, and which earned the bill two additional co-sponsors in Congress. APS also organizes annual Congressional Visit Days, in which advocates, including students, meet with members of Congress on Capitol Hill to make the case for important science issues. Last year’s event prioritized laws related to federal science funding and international STEM students.

Students sometimes “need to be offered a seat at the table before they believe they’ve earned one,” Jain writes.
APS

Although these forums exist, many students don’t know about them or don’t feel they belong in them. I’ve felt this too. How can I meaningfully contribute to a conversation with experienced policy wonks about, say, student visas? Will my email or letter make a splash, or even be read?

These doubts can be compounded by practical barriers. In professional societies and at universities, pathways for student representation are often not obvious. For many students, professional societies serve only as avenues to publish articles, attend conferences, or network. They may not realize that structured student committees exist in professional societies like APS, or that APS units encourage students to participate. From my own experience on FGSA, I’ve seen that APS leaders value our opinions and ask for the Executive Committee’s input on important issues.

Universities and professional societies can help. At universities, departments can communicate more clearly the student representative bodies that exist and their capabilities. Orientation and required introductory courses are ideal venues to introduce these bodies, explain their responsibilities, and show students how to get involved before they become immersed in their own research groups. Faculty advisors, to whom many students first turn for help, can reinforce this by introducing advisees to their graduate student representatives during initial meetings.

Departments can also create regular opportunities for students to engage directly with leadership. For example, the Georgia Tech Aerospace chair regularly holds separate office hours for undergraduate students, graduate students, research engineers, and faculty and staff, providing an accessible forum to raise concerns. For their part, university leadership can meet directly and regularly with student committees rather than taking ad hoc meetings based on student requests.

Professional societies can make student participation a routine part of their governance, too. Student representation should extend beyond dedicated student groups to technical committees and governing bodies, where students build relationships that open doors to new leadership and advocacy opportunities. Advocacy is just a small part of FGSA’s work, but I only became aware of APS’ broader advocacy resources after joining its executive committee. Since then, I have answered every campaign email, joined three other committees, and helped my colleagues do the same.

Societies can also integrate advocacy into activities members already attend. Even small changes, such as including brief updates on ongoing campaigns during conference plenaries, can introduce students to opportunities they would otherwise miss.

Sometimes, to encourage involvement in advocacy, students need to be offered a seat at the table before they believe they’ve earned one.

But smoothing the path to participation is only half the equation. We students must be willing to take the seats offered to us; we must be willing to advocate for ourselves and our peers even if we’re uncertain, and even if we doubt our impact.

Reassuringly for many, student advocates do not need to come to the discussion table with specialized knowledge or technical policy expertise. I’ve taken more than a dozen meetings with congressional representatives, and I can confirm from experience that bringing personal stories is enough — stories about, for example, how federal funding has positively impacted me, or why a diverse and international student body has helped my own learning and career.

Today, I can see more clearly how vital student voices are in debates about the future of the scientific enterprise. University and professional society leaders know our voices matter; they know that students now will be scientists tomorrow, inheriting the consequences of today’s decisions. Sometimes speaking up requires small but important acts, like submitting a letter to a member of Congress. Sometimes it takes a bigger leap.

Four years ago, when the FGSA Executive Committee was soliciting nominations, I threw my hat in the ring — my own big leap. It has paid off. It will pay off for you, too. What future for scientists do you envision? What leap will you take to make it a reality?

The views expressed in interviews and opinion pieces are not necessarily those of APS. APS News welcomes letters responding to these and other issues.

Ari Jain

Ari Jain is a fifth-year doctoral student in aerospace engineering at the Georgia Institute of Technology. Since 2023, he has served in numerous elected positions at APS, including on the Forum on Graduate Student Affairs and Panel on Public Affairs.

Join your Society

Advance your career, your field, and our world in a community where collaboration and curiosity drive scientific progress.