March 22, 2010

Helium rain on Jupiter

New research suggests that helium rain could be washing neon out of Jupiter's upper atmosphere

Illustration: Alan Stonebraker

This schematic depiction of the interior of a gas giant (e.g. Jupiter or Saturn) shows Helium-rich droplets forming within the immiscibility layer and raining downwards, leading to a slow increase in the helium concentration in the deep interior. Neon is absorbed in the droplets and carried out of the upper atmosphere.

Gray arrow  Larger Image
Gray arrow  Article in Physics

When NASA's Galileo probe reached Jupiter in 1995 and began sending back data about the gas giant, astronomers were in for a surprise: Jupiter was unusually poor in helium and neon, the two lightest noble gases. New simulations of the physics inside the planet reveal why. The results, which provide a glimpse into Jupiter's turbulent innards, are reported in the current issue of Physical Review Letters and highlighted with a Viewpoint by Jonathan Fortney (University of California, Santa Cruz) in the March 22 issue of Physics (

To understand how a planet might have formed and what the inside of it might be like, astronomers compare the abundances of its constituent elements with the amounts of those elements found in the sun and meteorites. Jupiter, like the sun, is mostly hydrogen and helium. But the Galileo probe showed that, while it was richer than the sun in six elements, the planet seemed to be missing a small amount of helium and a substantial amount of neon—although neon makes up 1/600 of the mass of the solar system, it made up only 1/6000 of the mass of Jupiter's upper atmosphere, where Galileo made its observations. Astronomers had assumed that Jupiter was a homogenous mix of hydrogen and helium, but this couldn't explain the observed lack of neon. Some physicists suggested that the neon was somehow sinking out of the upper atmosphere, but no one knew how this could happen.

A pair of astronomers from the University of California Berkeley has solved the mystery. Using computer simulations of the hot gases deep within the giant planet, the researchers have shown that there must be an atmospheric layer where helium condenses into droplets rather than mixing smoothly with hydrogen. Neon dissolves into these droplets, which gradually fall toward the planet's interior as helium rain. Not only do the simulations explain a long-standing mystery, but they also hint at what might be happening inside other planets. For instance, because Saturn is smaller and colder than Jupiter, physicists expect that helium rain will be even more prevalent inside this as-yet-unprobed planet.

APS Physics
APS Physics publishes expert written commentaries and highlights of papers appearing in the journals of the American Physical Society. 

In APS Physics This Week


About APS

The American Physical Society ( is a non-profit membership organization working to advance and diffuse the knowledge of physics through its outstanding research journals, scientific meetings, and education, outreach, advocacy and international activities. APS represents over 51,000 members, including physicists in academia, national laboratories and industry in the United States and throughout the world. Society offices are located in College Park, MD (Headquarters), Ridge, NY, and Washington, DC.

Media Contact