APS News

February 2019 (Volume 28, Number 2)

Synthesizing Current Research Succinctly and Elegantly

By Randall Kamien

Reviews of Modern Physics banner

Ninety years ago the editor of the Physical Review, John T. Tate, proposed “a new type of journal in Physics—a journal in which would appear reports and critical comments on the various branches of current thought and research.” He continues, “[w]e recognize the value of this kind of thing in so many ways—in the symposia we have at our meetings—in the seminars we hold in our research laboratories and universities. I would hope that this journal would extend the advantages of that sort of discussion to a much wider audience.”

Reviews of Modern Physics 90 years logo

Endorsed by a few dozen prominent physicists, a supplement to the Physical Review was created, now known as Reviews of Modern Physics. Long before the arXiv, fax machines, and express mail, this was a timely way to disseminate and educate. The very first article, on the probable value of the physical constants by Raymond Birge in 1929, was the forerunner to the Particle Data Group’s ongoing mission. Hans Bethe, with collaborators, published a series of review articles on nuclear physics in the 1930s that came to be known as the “Bethe bible.” In 1948, Richard Feynman published his article on the path integral approach to quantum mechanics. Over the years, David Mermin has published any number of insightful reviews, and the list goes on. Articles that are over 50 years old are still a delight to read and can teach us much, from physics to pedagogy.

Why can’t we replace this with video recorded lectures and disseminate ideas à la social media with hyperlinks serving up every definition and acronym, and routing us down every rabbit hole? Because good writing begets good reading, and good reading is a deliberate exercise, not a Sunday matinee. Joyce Carol Oates argues “that serious reading is as sacramental an act as serious writing…“ [1]. In a perfect world, everything we read and write would live up to this ideal.

Fortunately, Reviews of Modern Physics has been and remains a small, curated journal with about 11 articles per quarter: when the authors, referees, editors, and referees (the referees are very important and appreciated—two mentions may not be enough!) are giving their all, it is possible to aspire to this level of communication. Reviews of Modern Physics should be a pleasure to read on all levels: the articles should have strong and clear introductions to bring the reader up to speed; the content should not only be relevant but also elegantly and succinctly presented when possible; and there should be something for everyone in every issue.

Indeed, as the scope of APS expands through its membership, its publications, and its role in scientific outreach, Reviews of Modern Physics is taking steps to broaden the definition of “Modern Physics.” We have appointed an editor to cover climate science, we are expanding to solicit articles on fluids, applications, and materials, and we continue to expand into new areas, “physics broadly construed.” We have the distinct advantage that we are a journal that can plot our own course – we need not be swayed by the desire to promote our articles to the popular media and we can publish articles for our true constituents. Our sincere thanks go out to the authors, referees, and editors who continue to make this possible.

Randall D. Kamien is the Lead Editor of Reviews of Modern Physics and Vicki and William Abrams Professor in the Natural Sciences in the Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pennsylvania.


1. Joyce Carol Oates, “Literature as Pleasure, Pleasure as Literature,” in Woman Writer: Occasions and Opportunities (Dutton, 1988).

For more on the history of Reviews of Modern Physics, see the February 2019 special issue of Physics Today.

At both the March and April Meetings this year, Reviews of Modern Physics will host special symposia to encourage excellent scientific communication, celebrate our 90th anniversary, and look forward to the Reviews of the Future.

APS March Meeting – Reviews of Modern Physics: The First 90 Years, Tuesday, March 5, 7:30 - 9 p.m., Grand Ballroom A, Westin Boston Waterfront. For the latest information on the APS April Meeting sessions, see the April Meeting page.

APS encourages the redistribution of the materials included in this newspaper provided that attribution to the source is noted and the materials are not truncated or changed.

Editor: David Voss
Staff Science Writer: Leah Poffenberger
Contributing Correspondent: Alaina G. Levine
Publication Designer and Production: Nancy Bennett-Karasik

February 2019 (Volume 28, Number 2)

APS News Home

Issue Table of Contents

APS News Archives

Contact APS News Editor

Articles in this Issue
Synthesizing Current Research Succinctly and Elegantly
APS Bridge Program and the National Mentoring Community Visit Google HQ
APS Membership Unit Profile: The Topical Group on Medical Physics
One if by Land, Qubits by Sea: The 2019 APS March Meeting Heads to Boston
Impact of Women in STEM Roadshow in India
Fuzzy Fluid Dynamics
Q&A with Standard Bearer Steven Weinberg
The Dark Energy Survey’s Six-year Exploration Comes to An End
The 2018 Gallery of Fluid Motion Poster Winners
This Month in Physics History
News from the APS Office of Government Affairs
FYI: Science Policy News from AIP
The Back Page