Consolidated Interim Storage of Commercial Spent Nuclear Fuel
Approximately 54,000 tons of spent nuclear fuel are stored at operating nuclear power plants and several decommissioned power plants throughout the country. Spent fuel storage at these sites was never intended to be permanent. The current Federal plan is to place the fuel in a repository for permanent disposal in Nevada at Yucca Mountain.
Recently, appropriations committees in Congress suggested building one or more Federal sites for consolidated interim storage of spent fuel. Several reasons were identified. The schedule for opening Yucca Mountain continues to slip. Further, the Federal government faces substantial and growing liability costs the longer the spent fuel stays at reactor sites. Finally, there is a concern that the buildup of spent fuel at reactor sites and lack of progress on final disposition could be serious constraints on the growth of the domestic nuclear power industry by discouraging investment in new nuclear power plants and enhancing the difficulty of siting new nuclear power plants.We focus on the issues associated with proposals to establish one or more sites for the consolidated storage of spent nuclear power reactor fuel as an interim measure before final disposition. In reviewing numerous reports and research articles, we find that:
- There are no substantive safety or security reasons for establishing consolidated interim storage.
- There are no compelling cost savings to the Federal government associated with consolidated interim storage, so long as Yucca Mountain is not delayed well beyond its currently planned opening.
- There is sufficient space at all operating nuclear reactors to store all spent nuclear fuel in pools and in existing or additional dry casks that will be discharged even with plant license extensions. Although, some states may limit the amount of dry storage at a reactor site.
- Consolidated storage could facilitate the decommissioning of sites with reactors that have been shut down.
- Consolidated interim storage would establish a process for taking Federal title to commercial spent fuel and decouple private sector nuclear power plant operators from the long-term spent-fuel management problem, thereby removing a potential obstacle to siting new nuclear power plants and to continued operation of existing plants.
Such a decoupling could arguably also be accomplished if the Federal government took title to the spent fuel at the reactor sites.
A permanent repository is the cornerstone of the nation’s waste management strategy. Consequently, if the Federal government were to proceed with interim storage, it should be done in a manner consistent with Federal strategies for long-term management. Further, any development of consolidated interim storage must be sensitive to the significant hurdles to siting which would make it difficult to open a consolidated storage site in less than a decade. If Congress chooses to direct the development of consolidated storage facilities, the exploration of strategies to improve their economic and social attractiveness to potential host communities should receive careful consideration.
About APS & POPA
Founded in 1899 to advance and diffuse the knowledge of physics, the American Physical Society is now the nation’s leading organization of physicists with approximately 50,000 members in academia, national laboratories, and industry. APS has long played an active role in the federal government; its members serve in Congress and have held positions such as Science Advisor to the President of the United States, Director of the CIA, Director of the National Science Foundation and Secretary of Energy.
This report was overseen by the APS Panel on Public Affairs (POPA). POPA routinely produces reports on timely topics being debated in government so as to inform the debate with the perspectives of physicists working in the relevant issue areas.
Nuclear Energy Study Group
John Ahearne, Co-Chair
Robert J. Budnitz
Roger Hagengruber, Co-Chair
Ernest J. Moniz
Francis Slakey, Advisor